What happens when a company has already invested in major infrastructure and the European Union changes the rules before construction is complete? This is one of the questions at the heart of the judgment of 5 November 2026, in which the Court of Justice dismissed the appeal brought by the company behind the gas pipeline linking Russia and Germany (Case C-118/25 P, Nord Stream 2 v Parliament and Council).
The dispute arose from Directive (EU) 2019/692, which extended certain EU internal gas market rules to pipelines connecting Member States with third countries, as regards the sections situated within Member States’ territory and territorial waters. These rules include the separation of gas supply from network operation (unbundling) and third-party access to transmission capacity. The directive also allowed Member States, under certain conditions, to grant derogations for pipelines completed before 23 May 2019. Nord Stream 2 did not qualify.
The litigation has followed a complicated path. In 2022, the Court of Justice held that the action was admissible in so far as it challenged the provision governing derogations. In 2024, the General Court dismissed the action on its merits. The latest judgment upholds that decision and clarifies that the earlier ruling on admissibility had not established that Nord Stream 2 had suffered unjustified unequal treatment.
The most interesting aspect concerns the protection of legitimate expectations. The company argued, in substance, that its existing investments should have warranted a transitional regime or compensation. The Court noted, however, that the EU institutions had given no precise and unconditional assurances that the previous regulatory framework would continue to apply. On the contrary, the prospect of extending EU gas market rules to pipelines from third countries had been apparent for years. The Court also reaffirmed the purpose of third-party access requirements: they concern access to transport capacity, including potential future requests, not merely the physical possibility of connecting another pipeline.
The conclusion deserves some care. The Court was not deciding whether Nord Stream 2 was a sound political choice, nor was it ruling on sanctions against Russia. It confirmed instead that a major investment, even one with clear geopolitical significance, does not in itself confer immunity from a foreseeable change in EU market regulation. The intersection of strategic infrastructure, investor expectations and the EU’s regulatory powers is precisely what makes this case worth following.
Further reading: Case C-118/25 P on InfoCuria; Directive (EU) 2019/692 on EUR-Lex. The account of the judgment is based on the Court of Justice’s Press Release No 160/26 of 5 November 2026.

Leggi in Italiano